5 Best Shaving Soap for Sensitive Skin

Updated Date: by Reet Patel

Sensitive skin needs a lot of pampering, which starts from picking up the right shaving tools and shaving accessories.  For shaving tools, you may go through the best electric shaver for sensitive skin articles.  And for the shaving accessories, the first thing you should consider is the best shaving soap for sensitive skin.

Conventional shaving soaps are good for the normal skin type but when it comes to sensitive or allergic skin, it requires extended research and understanding of the ingredients that may irritate your skin.  Using ordinary soaps on sensitive skin may lead to skin issues, such as skin irritation, itching, and pain.  That’s an alarming and intimidating situation.

In the world of ample information, it becomes a daunting task to find the best shaving soap for sensitive skin.  Don’t worry at all, this article is a compilation of the shaving soaps that take care of sensitive skin.  Also, you may know the essential things to consider before buying a shave soap.  What are the benefits and how is it different from shaving creams is a must to know the topic. 

So, keep reading the article and buy one of the shaving soaps for yourself or gift it to your loved ones.

In a Hurry? Here Are Our Top 3 Picks

Proraso Shaving Soap In A Bowl
  • Item Weight: 0.18 Kilograms
  • Age Range (Description): Adult
Taylor of Old Bond Street Sandalwood Shaving Cream
  • Scent: Sandalwood
  • Item Weight: 0.25 Kilograms
  • Skin Type: All
  • Age Range (Description): Adult
Mitchell’s Wool Fat Shave Soap
  • Skin Type: Sensitive
  • Age Range (Description): Adult
  • Size: 4.4 Ounce (Pack of 1)

Quick Comparison of the Best Shaving Soap for Sensitive Skin

Proraso Shaving Soap

Proraso Shaving Soap

Check Price
Mitchell’s Wool Fat Shave Soap

Mitchell’s Wool Fat Shave Soap

Check Price
Taylor of Old Bond Street Sandalwood Shaving Cream

Taylor of Old Bond Street Sandalwood Shaving Cream

Check Price
Men’s Soap Company Shave Soap

Men’s Soap Company Shave Soap

Check Price
Colonel Conk Bay Rum Shaving Soap

Colonel Conk Bay Rum Shaving Soap

Check Price

Proraso Shaving Soap

Proraso Shaving Soap In A Bowl
  • Ingredients: Eucalyptus Oil 
  • Fragrance: Menthol

Proraso has been serving in the grooming industry with a wide variety of accessories since 1908.  And anyone who’s been regularly buying shaving products has heard the name of Proraso.  An early bird should know that the Proraso is a king of wet shaving.  

The priority of Proraso shaving soap is to eliminate skin rashes and reduce cuts and nicks.  Also, it softens the skin by producing sufficient lather that offers an effortless shave.  The shave soap comes in a bowl that ensures it lasts for a long time.

Talking about the recipe, it contains all-natural, cruelty-free, and eco-friendly ingredients.  A blend of glycerin and coconut oil moisturizes the skin, eliminating rashes.  On top of it, the eucalyptus oil ensures that it purifies and tones the skin.  Menthol makes sure that you receive a cool and revitalizing feeling post-shave.  Therefore,  it is the best shaving soap for sensitive skin.

  • Soft creamy lather
  • No parabens & chemicals
  • Builds lather quickly
  • Clean and close shave
  • Protect skin from cuts and nicks
  • Lather leaves a white residue on the shaving tool
  • Unpleasant smell

Mitchell’s Wool Fat Shave Soap

Mitchell’s Wool Fat Shave Soap
  • Ingredients: Natural Lanolin
  • Fragrance: Glycerin

Fred Mitchell was a chemist, who introduced the first wool fat soap in the 1930s.  He got this idea when he noticed that the natural lanolin wool fat is the reason behind the soft hands of wool sorters and shearers.  This made him think that if this can soften the hand then why not try it on the face. 

The critical ingredient ensures that the skin remains soft and moisturized.  This lanolin content wool fat shaves soap is one of the best shaving soaps on the market.  The thick and cushiony lather protects the skin from the sharp razor blades.  Apart from natural lanolin, it contains sodium tallowate, sodium cocoate, potassium stearate, potassium cocoate, and glycerin.

These ingredients ensure that it clean and lubricate the skin while restoring the charm.  Also, glycerin does not fail in moisturizing the skin and contributes to lathering as well.  This helps the blades to glide on the skin easily and smoothly.  On top of it, it makes the skin fresh, smooth, and moisturizing.

  • No harsh chemical or animal testing done
  • Made up of natural lanolin
  • Pleasant, mild, and relaxing scent
  • No soap bowl or dish
  • Chances of dissipation of lather

Taylor of Old Bond Street Sandalwood Shaving Cream

Taylor of Old Bond Street Sandalwood Shaving Cream
  • Ingredients: Sandalwood & Glycerin
  • Fragrance: Sandalwood

Taylor of Old Bond Street is a renowned shaving accessories manufacturer in the United Kingdom.  It was established in 1854 and since its inception, it aims to deliver shaving soaps that are worth every penny.  And this is proven from its casing in which the shaving soap is packed and delivered.  It comes in a sturdy wooden bowl with a wooden top for a pleasing appearance.

As the name says, it contains a hint of sandalwood that delivers a soothing and amazing shaving experience by nourishing the skin and not letting it dry.  Applying this Taylor of Old Bond shaving soap before shaving will moisturize the skin and prepare it for shaving.  The shave soap produces a soft, thick, and rich lather that is luxurious and manly for shaving.

The shave soap also contains glycerin to moisturize and deliver a pleasant feeling aftershave.  This is made up of natural ingredients and no harmful chemicals are included.  Also, it is free from animal testing.  It requires less water and time to build lather.  And you can achieve the best lather only if you use the best shaving brush to create it.  Overall, it is one of the best shave soaps for sensitive skin.

  • Excellent wooden container
  • Friction-free shaving
  • Lasts long due to its creamy nature
  • Build lather quickly with less water
  • Nourishes and moisturizes skin
  • Smooth shave and mild smell
  • Moisture doesn’t remain for a long time
  • Thick and sticky residue isn’t easily washable
  • Expensive

Men’s Soap Company Shave Soap

Men’s Soap Company Shave Soap
  • Ingredients: Vegan Plant
  • Fragrance:  Subtle Himalaya

Men’s soap company is known for its quality shaving essentials for men of all ages.  And out of the amazing product line, we have picked up the Coconut Oil and Shea Butter Shave Soap for Men.  This shaving soap saves from skin issues, such as cuts, nicks, and razor burns.  All skin types – sensitive, irritated, or natural can use this soap.  

It is a blend of natural ingredients, such as Vitamin E, Sweet Almond Oil, Coconut Oil, and Shea Butter.  And every ingredient has its contribution in making this shaving soap soft, thick, and amazing on sensitive skin.  While Shea Butter moisturizes the skin and facial hair and protects from UV radiation, the Sweet almond oil, on the other hand, increases growth on your skin. 

Also, shaving soap is free from harmful chemicals, parabens, hair dyes, and artificial colors.  Moreover, a subtle Himalaya fragrance that comes with this shave soap is relaxing and mild.

  • Made up of all essential oils and natural ingredients
  • Mild and relaxing subtle Himalaya fragrance
  • Lather ensure a rich shaving experience
  • Shea Butter & Glycerin makes sure the skin feels soft and smooth
  • Not good lather build for thick and coarse hair
  • Soap melts quickly
  • Pricey shaving soap

Colonel Conk Bay Rum Shaving Soap

Colonel Conk Bay Rum Shaving Soap
  • Ingredients: Avocado oil & Vitamin E
  • Fragrance: Bay Rum

Colonel Conk Shaving Soap is the biggest manufacturer of glycerin-based soaps for more than 150 years.  These soaps are unique and proven to be delivering a pleasing shaving experience.  It ensures that its users get a close, clean, and smooth shave.

The shaving soap is built out of plant-based ingredients that include essential oils and natural ingredients.  Talking about the fragrance, the soap contains a mild tropical scent that is appealing, pleasant, and not overpowering.  What is commendable is it quickly creates a creamy lather that not only offers a close shave but also prevents the skin from cuts and nicks.

The natural ingredients include avocado oil which is rich in Vitamin E and Omega 3 fatty acids that help in relaxing the dry and sensitive skin.  The glycerin is responsible for the easy movement of the safety razor on the face is part of this shaving soap.  What’s not part of this soap is; gluten, synthetics, artificial colors, and/or DEA.  It makes the Colonel Conk Bay Rum the best shaving soap for sensitive skin.

  • Comes in a pack of three (affordable than single soap)
  • Quickly lathers
  • Vitamin E and Avocado oil for extra moisturizing
  • Bay Rum Scent not so overpowering
  • Weak lather requires more application

So these were the best shaving soap reviews, now you must go through the below section to know the actual things to consider before investing in it.

Buying Guide: Things to Consider Before You Buy A Shaving Soap

What is the best shaving soap for sensitive skin?


It is important to know the ingredients before you buy soap for sensitive skin.  You should not simply buy a product that says “natural” or “organic,” and should further investigate the product. Even menthol, clove oil, cinnamon, eucalyptus oil, mint, and lanolin may cause skin irritations, rashes, and razor burns.

There should be no parabens, phthalates, or gluten in the shaving product.  The natural ingredients are the reason you feel a cooling sensation post-shaving.  No animal cruelty and no hazardous chemicals 

Lather Quality

The shaving soap should be easy to lather and doesn’t require extra attention.  The money you spend on the soap should be worth it.  If the shaving soap creates a rich lather then it is worth every penny.  The lather is responsible for friction-free shaving easy movement of a shaving tool on the skin.

What’s a noticeable point is the time a shaving soap takes to produce quality lather?  Generally, a shaving soap takes 30 seconds to 50 seconds to create a foamy and rich lather.


Though the essential oils come with several benefits, it still falls short in many different factors, such as skin irritations, itchiness, redness, and breakouts.  These essential oils are the reason behind the overpowering and heady aromas that you get out of your shaving accessories.

An unscented shaving soap could be your shaving product if you wanna get rid of the unpleasant smell coming out of it. Also, it will ensure no pain or discomfort.

Skin Protection

The skin protection depends on the lather quality.  If it is thick then it will create a layer between the skin and the safety razor, ensuring the razor blades easily glide without cutting your skin.  Good shaving soap is one that produces quality lather and also prevents cuts and nicks.

With the use of quality shaving soap, you will save yourself from razor bumps and burns.  Also, you should check whether the shaving soap you consider offers a cooling sensation or not.

Now that you know what factors to look for at the time of buying a shaving soap, let’s also look at the benefits you get from using a shaving soap.  After all, you are investing your hard-earned money into a product and if it doesn’t come with benefits then it isn’t worth it.

Benefits of Using Shaving Soap for Your Sensitive Skin

There are mainly 4 benefits of using shaving soap for sensitive skin.  Let’s discuss this in detail.

Why should you use a shaving soap?

Moisturizes the Skin

If you are looking for a moisturizing effect then shaving soap tops the chart. It moisturizes the skin so much than any other product could do.  These are made up of natural ingredients that help to soften the facial hair and skin.  It is advisable to use shaving soap for men with dry skin.

Works Great on your Skin

Shaving soaps are superior to creams as they form a rich and quality lather that can cover the facial hair with a minimum amount.  This will allow the razors to glide easily on the face without any fear of nicks and cuts.  Also, it makes sure that no area is left unshaved.  That becomes one of the reasons for the razor user to use shaving soaps over the shaving creams.


Many famous brands like Proraso, Mitchell, and Colonel Conk use no harmful chemicals or parabens while making shaving soaps.  It makes the shaving soap skin-friendly, eliminating the risk of side effects caused by numbing agents by not including it in the ingredient list.  The key ingredients in shaving soaps are Aloe Vera, natural oils, and glycerin.


Shaving soaps are often scented due to the use of menthol, vanilla, and citrus while formulating the ingredients.  Other shaving products do not contain scents at all, whereas shaving soap tends to spread the aroma.  Not all the shaving soaps are aromatic, few come unscented as well.

Last but not the least, the major point to understand, i.e., the difference between shaving cream and soap.  The lathering quality of both accessories is the same but there remain a few differences.  So, let’s check out.

Shaving Soap vs Shaving Cream

 What is the difference between shaving soap and shaving cream?

Wet shaving is a crucial game and one needs to excel in it.  A newbie would stumble when it comes to choosing a shaving cream or shaving soap. The selection depends on personal preference and choice.

Shaving soaps are a traditional accessory that is serving the industry for more than centuries, while shaving cream is a modern modification that focuses on convenience and speeding up the process.  Let’s look at the major differences.


Here, the entire shaving game depends on the type of razors you choose.  If your grooming arsenal includes a safety razor then a shaving cream is worth investing in, and if you prefer a straight razor then shaving soap could quickly build rich lather.  The lather makes way for the razor to glide and shave, preventing razor burns, bumps, and skin irritation.


Shaving creams come with strong, powerful, and a variety of aromas.  Due to overpowering, it may or may not be liked by men, regardless of the skin type.  One needs to understand what is tolerant and what isn’t.  The strong fragrance may cause skin irritation, especially to men with sensitive skin.  On the other hand, shaving soap for sensitive skin comes with a sweet aroma that remains unnoticeable.  That’s the reason sensitive skin men can choose shaving soap over the shaving cream.

Hard Water

Hard water works well with shaving cream and not shaving soap.  Both the water and shaving soap is hard and that’s why it would be difficult to create lather.  If your area has hard water then you must use shaving cream.


Shaving cream already contains water, which means lathering it would be easier as compared to shaving soap for sensitive skin.  Also, it would not require a shaving brush to create lather.  On the contrary, shaving soaps that are harder in nature requires a lot of brushing to create lather.  But one thing is a fact, though the shaving soaps take time for building lather it tends to create the most luxurious lather over the shaving cream.

With this, we end our article but will answer a few commonly asked questions.  So, keep reading and it might have answers to your questions as well.


1. What is the best shaving soap for sensitive skin?

The article has a list that consists of the best shaving soap for men with sensitive skin. You can go through the article and if you are in a hurry then Proraso, Colonel Conk, and Mitchell are a few sensitive skin shaving soap brands.

2. What is the best way to shave if you have sensitive skin?

The best way to shave on sensitive skin is to shave with the grain. This means you must glide your razor in the direction of hair growth.

3. Is Shave Soap better than cream?

You cannot say which one is better as it entirely depends on personal choice and a few factors discussed in the differences section of this article. You must know what suits you best and then add it to your grooming accessory.


Shaving soaps get rid of the issues like razor burns and irritations.  This is often a problem with sensitive skin and may leave red marks on the skin after shaving.  Ideally, the good shaving soap contains high-quality ingredients, such as green tea, mango butter, essential and natural oils.  This helps in moisturizing and nourishing skin.  Also, it eliminates the dry skin issue.

We hope the article finds you well and you got sufficient information about your skin type.  You can share your experience, suggestions, and feedback.  Also, you can subscribe to our website for more such good reads.


Published Date: Dec 11, 2020

Sign up for weekly updates from Tomfw.